Canon and Nikon Enthusiast Full-Frames at Photokina

What Pentax Ricoh's future full-frame will be up against

By PF Staff in Photokina 2012 on Oct 5, 2012
Canon and Nikon Enthusiast Full-Frames at Photokina

Canon and Nikon showcased new "intro-level" full-frame DSLRs at Photokina this year, both of which are in the low-$2000 price range. The two cameras are design-wise typical members of their respective brands: the Canon 6D with a simplistic design and a smoth and quiet shutter, and the Nikon D600 with a sharper design, buttons sprinkled all over, and a loud and aggressive shutter sound. 

A thorough evaluation isn't possible at a trade show like this, so what we can offer is subjective first impressions and some photos of the products.

Canon and Nikon went separate ways in this segment just like they did in the mid-range segment with the Canon 5D Mark III and the Nikon D800, respectively. Canon took the more conservative approach with "just" 20 MP in the 6D, whereas the Nikon D600 offers up 24 MP. Only a thorough test can reveal if the Canon will win in noise comparison. It's practically a given that it will lag behind in resolution.

Read on for technical specifications and our first impressions!  While both camera seemed like fine additions to their respective lineups, it's clear that certain features were left out merely to justify the lower price points.  This yields a gap in the market which we're sure Pentax Ricoh could fill, for example by releasing an affordable full-frame with in-camera stabilization, a 1/8000s shutter, and superior framerates for both stills and videos.  As long as this hypothetical Pentax body would retain the excellent handling and user interface of the current bodies, we are sure it be a worthy rival for the other intro-level full-frames.

Both cameras attracted a lot of attention and the crowds were big:

congregation at D600

The D600 button layout:

D600D600 front

The 6D button layout:

6D backCanon 6D front

Canon 6D and Nikon D600 Technical Specifications

Canon 6D
Nikon D600
Sensor 20.2 MP, 24 x 36 mm 24.3 MP, 24 x 36 mm
Sensitivity

ISO 100 - 25,600

(50 - 102,800 expanded)

ISO 100 - 6,400

(50 - 25,600 expanded)

Shutter

30 s to 1/4,000 s

1/180 s flash sync

30 s to 1/4,000 s

1/200 s flash sync

Burst rate 4.5 fps 5 fps
Focus points

11 (1 cross-type)

Sensitivity -3 EV (center),

+0.5 EV other points

39

Sensitivity to -1 EV

Monitor 3 inch, 1,040,000 dots 3.2 inch, 921,000 dots
Viewfinder

97%, 0.71x

Exchangeable screens

100%, 0.7x
Video

H.264, MPEG-4, MOV

Full HD at 25/30 fps

720p at up to 60 fps

HDMI out

H.264, MPEG-4, MOV

Full HD at 24/25/30 fps

720p at up to 60 fps

HDMI out

Built-in mic Mono

Mono

External mic No

Stereo

Weather resistant Yes

Yes

Size (BxHxD) 145 x 111 x 71 mm

141 x 113 x 82 mm

Built-in flash No

Yes

Weight (loaded) 770 g

760 g

Other

Built-in GPS and Wi-fi

No support for EF-S lenses

Two SD card slots

Supports APS-C (DX) lenses

Subjective

first impression

Quiet shutter

Fast and surefooted autofocus

Good ergonomics

Loud and sharp shutter noise

Very fast autofocus

Confusing button layout

The Nikon D600 is already available for sale whereas the Canon 6D is about two months out (it is scheduled to start shipping on December 10th).

Concluding, the two camera are very different despite having the same pricetags.  It's clear that lens lineups, not just the bodies, will be what will attract customers to these cameras.  We tend to prefer the direction Canon has taken with their 6D, though only time will tell which of the two cameras produces better photographs!

Comments

 

 


fb.com/PentaxForums PentaxForums +Pentax Forums @PentaxForums News | Reviews | Forum

Support Pentax Forums Donate to Pentax Forums Support Pentax Forums