Originally posted by jeff knight So with all 50mm AF Pentax lenses, irregardless of the length of the lens extension, the camera has the data to properly calculate shake reduction? Or does it just apply a 50mm one-size-fits-all caculation for all 50mm AF lenses? I
The Pentax SR is based on the camera sensor, so its different from some other brands, which have the stabilization in the lens. In-body SR, as Pentax has (and Sony, Olympus, I think), doesn't care about the lens size or weight, it only tries to bring the sensor in line with the shake. It stabilizes the sensor, not the lens. This is why Pentax cameras have a "clanking" sound if you rattle them - the magnets holding the sensor are floating. And also this is why you shouldn't just go around rattling cameras
As far as we know, 50mm is 50mm, but it is possible that Pentax has some special profiles for their own lenses. It has profiles for things like CA correction and distortion correction, so maybe it has some slight optimizations for the SR as well. Maybe the DA 50mm f1.8 would have slightly better SR than an ancient manual 50mm, but I really doubt it would be a noticeable change. I use SR with manual lenses and never noticed a difference, so it is either small or nonexistent. And I never heard or read about such a differences, either.
Anyway, your F or FA or DFA 50mm macro lens should have fine SR. But for macro work you usually want to use a tripod and flashes anyway. Handheld macros at those magnifications are difficult, even in daylight.
Edit: in-body SR has some advantages. It doesn't cause motion in the viewfinder (so no motion sickness), it works for all lenses, even ancient manual ones, wide angle or not (for other brands, you might not be able to find a stabilized version of every lens). The only downside is, according to some people, that telephoto lenses have an advantage with in-lens stabilization. Not sure how true that is, but some people make that claim. On the other hand, you will have a hard time finding UWA lenses that are stabilized, but that's not a problem for in-body SR.