View Single Post
Old 01-10-2007, 08:54 AM   #9
Duncan J Murray
Member
 
Duncan J Murray's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Oxford, UK
Gallery Photos: 10
Posts: 70
Voted for 12, but had hard time choosing between that and 18.

Went for 12 for it's pleasing composition, technical excellence (just the right sharpness) and for it being a slightly new take on sunsets. I like the horizon, too - I find it evocative - like a city skyline made of clouds.

18 had a start abstractness to it, which, for me, nearly had the makings of really excellent photograph. I liked the monochrome simplicity and starkness, and simplified composition. In the end I found the composition unsettling - but I can't actually say why. Maybe because it went off the left, but not the right side, but who knows?

I haven't mentioned the other photos, of which I find some very impressive photography.

Duncan.
Duncan J Murray is offline