View Single Post
05-11-2008, 04:35 PM   #19
woof
Site Supporter
 
Location: In the present
Gallery Photos: 1
Posts: 1,007
Good review. You said two things that I am not sure of.

>> One interesting thing though is that while operating zoom ring the sound it makes reminds
>> me of a sound you would produce by scratching a nylon jacket or bag with your fingernail,
>> but I have checked other lenses in the store and confirmed with Ed, and it is apparently
>> normal.

Good description of the sound but on mine it is barely audible. I really mean ** barely **. You have to be listening for it. The general impression during normal operation is that it is silent. Nice and firm, but silent.

>> Don't be surprised though by noisy focusing ring while manually focusing: although it turns
>> smoothly you can hear all the gears turning inside. Again, it appears to be normal.

Mine does not do that at ALL. Silent as can be. I would suggest that this sound you are hearing is NOT right. I'd like to hear from tohers though.

Again. Goos review, thanks.

woof
woof is offline