PentaxForums.com - View Single Post - Now that the Pentax 17-70 is out... what carry around lens??

*FHPhotographer* · 07-20-2008, 05:40 PM

Originally Posted by Pentakun

(Sorry this got posted to the SLR Film Thread. I am reposting here)

I am very ready to upgrade from the 18-55 kit lens and have been considering either the Sigma 17-70 or Tamron 17-50, favoring the Sigma because of the longer zoom. But now that the Pentax 17-70 is out, I am wondering if I should get that? Price wise the Pentax is A LOT more, but maybe worth it. The Pentax new is about $200 more than either a new Tamron or Sigma; or $200 more than either of the two.

Just wondering what any of you might have to say about these lenses and which, if any, would you suggest for a carry around, all factors considered.

Appreciate the feedback.

Are you using a K10 or newer body? If not the older bodies will not auto focus the 17-70, so unless you plan to do a lot of manual focus, I'd stay away from the 17-70.

You might consider the Tamron 28-75 f/2.8 unless you need the wider angle at 18mm. It outscores the Pentax 16-50, and holds it's own at 70mm with the very highly regarded Sigma and Pentax 70 primes.
FHPhotographer

07-20-2008, 05:40 PM	#7
FHPhotographer Site Supporter Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Fountain Hills, AZ Gallery Photos: 1 Posts: 338	Originally Posted by Pentakun (Sorry this got posted to the SLR Film Thread. I am reposting here) I am very ready to upgrade from the 18-55 kit lens and have been considering either the Sigma 17-70 or Tamron 17-50, favoring the Sigma because of the longer zoom. But now that the Pentax 17-70 is out, I am wondering if I should get that? Price wise the Pentax is A LOT more, but maybe worth it. The Pentax new is about $200 more than either a new Tamron or Sigma; or $200 more than either of the two. Just wondering what any of you might have to say about these lenses and which, if any, would you suggest for a carry around, all factors considered. Appreciate the feedback. Are you using a K10 or newer body? If not the older bodies will not auto focus the 17-70, so unless you plan to do a lot of manual focus, I'd stay away from the 17-70. You might consider the Tamron 28-75 f/2.8 unless you need the wider angle at 18mm. It outscores the Pentax 16-50, and holds it's own at 70mm with the very highly regarded Sigma and Pentax 70 primes. FHPhotographer __________________ It's not the tool ...it's the toolmaker