#1 has a lot going for it, but the ordinary lighting and awkward pose (see her neck, hunched shoulders, crooked back) take too much out of the appeal for the model IMO.
I tend to agree with ash, but the pose is good. But it would look much better if she was more straight in the pose. Such fashion pose must look easy for the model to do, but in this shoot it shows to much tension.
but anyway thumbs up nice to see such nice work here.