Maybe someone else can chime in and correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure that on an SDM ready body the camera won't revert to screw-drive with the TC on.
On an older body (pre-SDM) I'm not sure what would happen.
I haven't actually used the Sigma 1.4x TC so I can't comment directly on the IQ. I have used the Tamron 1.4x Pz-AF on several different lenses (including the DA*300) and I feel the IQ is pretty good. The SDM focus is retained when using the Tamron, although the AF tends to hunt a little more and doesn't always lock on the first try.
Originally posted by Eruditass Even though the DA* has both focus capabilities? that sucks.
Are the Sigma TC's notably better than other brands optic wise (despite their incompatibilities)?