Originally posted by Blue Yes it will.
The confusion in this thread arises from the notion that macro photography is about filling the frame.
Well, to be precise, to quote the OP, it was about taking the same picture with two different cameras. And if you take pictures with the same magnification ratio on cameras with different format sizes, I guarantee they will *not* look like the same picture. The one on the larger format will show the subject smaller within the frame. That's just a fact. One can debate the relevance of that fact (I find pretty relevant, and apparently the OP does, but if others don't find it relevant to their own photography, that's fine). But there is no denying the fact itself - you need *different* magnification ratios to achieve the same shot between cameras of different format sizes, just as you need different focal lengths.
Quote: You don't need macro to photograph a 72mm subject.
Call it what you want, but you need a magnification of 1:2 to fill the frame with a 72mm subject on FF, and since someone else brought up the idea of achieving results comparable to 1:2 on FF, I used that in my example as well.
Quote: "crop factor" nor focal length will effect the 1:1 or 1:2 ratio.
Right - it affects the way the picture looks, which is the actual subject here, not the numbers that describe how the picture was taken.
Quote: The only difference in the DA 35 and Sigma 105mm in my above example is the focus distance at 1:1. They are both 1:1 capable lenses and the format won't change that.
Well, sure, but no one was talking about comparing a 35mm lens to a 105mm lens. Of course they produce different images because their FOV's are different. That's why I used the example of a 35mm macro lens on APS-C but 50mm on FF - so the FOV's would match. That in turn means if you get the subject to match, the background will match, too. The physics of perspective won't allow it to be ny other way. And once you get subject and background to match, you'll discover that you're dealing with two different magnification ratios, just as I said.