Originally posted by Lowell Goudge how about another approach.
Some of us have both film and digital bodies.
I have a PZ-1 for example.
Given the option, I would take FA's and use them on both.
Aside from that, as adam said some FA-s are a little bit better.
Surely this is the case of the FA-77F1.8 over the DA-70F2.4.
Aside from the 1 stop faster and shallower DOF for those who want it.
Hi Lowell,
Got to disagree with your assessment here Lowell. I'm not so sure the FA 77/1.8 is so much better as it is different than the DA 70/2.4. Both are fine lenses. I think it depends on what you are looking for in a lens. Yes, the 77is a little faster but has some issues with PFs which is not the case with the DA70/2.8. Klaus' dpreview review of the DA 70 provides a good comparison:
Verdict
The Pentax SMC DA 70mm f/2.4 Limited is an great lens with no really significant technical weakness. The resolution characteristic is generally excellent regardless of the (tested) aperture setting and the resolution distribution is much more harmonic compared to the SMC FA 77mm f/1.8 Limited although it sacrifices a tiny bit of peak performance. The vignetting is slightly more pronounced than desirable at f/2.4 but not really an issue beyond. Neither distortions nor CAs are field-relevant. You may be able to spot some traces of purple fringing. An interesting aspect of a large aperture tele lens is quality of the bokeh (the out-of-focus blur). Similar to its alcoholic counterpart it is a matter of taste to some degree - I'd say it is very good but not excellent. Here and there some of the out-of-focus halos seem to be a bit hard edged. The degree of background/foreground blur is also a bit limited by the comparatively small max. aperture (for a moderate tele lens). Typical for all Pentax Limited lenses the build quality is excellent and it is a joy to use such a high quality lens in the field. The price (around 500/US$) is quite fair in relation to what you get here. Now is it a "better" lens than the FA 77mm f/1.8 Limited ? I'd be hard pressed to provided a real guidance here. Technically the DA 70mm is a bit better (more even resolution, less purple fringing) whereas the FA 77mm has a slight edge regarding the bokeh due to its larger max. aperture. Fortunately the choice is yours and not mine ... :-)
Klaus spends a lot more time testing lenses than any of us and I bow to his opinion in this area. I choose the DA 70 as it was less expensive and the FA 77 didn't seem to offer that much more (to me) for the added expense. As Klaus says the choice is up to you. In a perfect world I'd have one of each.
Tom G