Originally posted by Canada_Rockies Another thing that can seriously affect my decision is the direction in which the zoom, aperture and focus controls turn or push and pull. I want them all to turn in the same direction to do the same thing. The last thing I want to do is to change lenses and zoom in the wrong direction when the image is fleeting.
Oddly enough, when I compare lenses for myself, if I cant find a feature or two that are "tipping points" in my decisions, I fall back on this very thing as well. When the zooming or focusing goes in opposite directions than Im used to, I can get fouled up at a critical time.
I personally own the DA* 16-50. My first copy had a decentering issue, but after sending it back to Pentax, I received a new copy which was MUCH better! (1.5-2 stops better sharpness on the corners/edges). My coworker and friend who also shoots pentax, after borrowing that lens a couple of times, determined he needed a constant f/2.8 zoom in the same range. He couldnt afford the Pentax so after research he went with the Tamron. The IQ to dollar advantage CLEARLY goes to the Tamron. The going price is nearly half of what the Pentax is ($750ish vs $450ish often with rebates taking that price to closer to $400). Personally though, I prefer the overall rendition of the Pentax (color and microcontrast) to the Tamron. The build quality of both lenses is superb. The Pentax offers the weather sealing as well as quick shift that the Tamron does not. Ultimately, the biggest differences in the lenses are the physical traits, as the image qualities are close. If money is no object, the DA* is a great option, however on a budget, the Tamron wont dissapoint. I hear the Sigma is also OK, but the Tamron does have rounded aperture blades, which was a tipping point for my friend when he bought it.