the 50-135 is on my want list, not as a [portrait lens but for events (other alternative is a 70-200 in my case)
it would be a fine addition to any kit
i recommended the wider option really because for most people a large percentage of their shooting falls in the 24-70 range and they are very good lenses for low prices (mine was less than $400 cdn), allowing perhaps a good manual focus a lens or two and still falling well below the 1000 price cap. an a 50 1.4 should be available for <150 and an A 35 f2.0 for close quarter is also a reasonable price lens if you can find one
M lenses you'll do even better being able to get the 100 macro or 100 2.8 for reasonable prices but with a little more difficulty in use
Sigma is a heavy bugger i'll admit, but it is a great lens
I haven't tried the tamron but also have not heard anything but positive reviews
Last edited by eddie1960; 12-14-2010 at 01:24 PM.