Originally posted by JeffJS His cons...
1. I've experienced it too and can make any lens do it, especially wide open.
2. No FA lens I've ever owned had quick shift. The DA lenses do as do the DFA lenses. An easy work around is to hold the lens release button while turning the focus ring (also works for catch in focus).
3. Huh?
This tells me he doesn't know how to use his Pentax Cameras. (Use Aperture Ring = Permitted)
4. Must be an old review. Pentax added the FA limiteds to the corrected list in a firmware update (or he doesn't keep his k7 up to date).
5. Originally Built for a full frame body.
6. Never a problem for me but personal preference prevails I guess.
7. Again, personal preference... I kind of like the Bokeh of the 43.
8. Expensive, Yes. Especially after the 2009 add on Pentax Tax. Hard to find? No. Hard to find at a willing to pay price? Probably.
9. As are all the screw drive lenses. I tend however to blame the camera more than the lens.
My Black one was made in Japan and yes, I'm the original owner of that one.
Overall though, his review doesn't really knock the lens. He just states he prefers something different (DA35 Macro).
Most of the "cons" list can be applied to most lenses made for film bodies.
Some of the so-called weaknesses relate to the camera body or
are akin to saying your expensive Porsche is bad because it has a stick shift when everyone just knows it must have an automatic transmission in order to be a good car.
A few years ago the FA43's worst enemies was our own Pentax user base. There were a few (not many, just a few) Pentax users who roundly criticized this lens for all sorts of misdemeaners - bad bokeh, unsharp, soft corners, unable to pick up a hot date when seen in public with the lens, etc etc. Yick. They then posted their complaints over and over and over and over again.
This was more or less taken as gospel by many Pentax shooters who never really tried the lens. All because if someone says it on the internet it must be true. Then a few leaders on sites like DPR tried this lens and disproved the naysayers, and now the FA43 is a highly regarded lens.
On DPR I did read on good authority from Canon users that all the FA Limiteds are only manual focus lenses. This must be true because "someone" said it on the internet.