Originally posted by GeneV Aside from completely new lenses (like the A*) there are very few A lenses that are upgrades over M counterparts. The only one that comes to mind is the 28mm/2.8, and that is an upgrade to an already excellent lens. (The last runs of the M 28 without serial numbers on the front are the new formula) Most of the time, the advantage of the A is the ability to use the full features of the DSLR metering and P-TTL flash. That is a definite advantage, and it seems that more and more, when I buy an M lens, I primarily have a film body in mind and/or I can't resist the price.
Gene,
Daniel Cecchi in his book Ashai Pentax and Pentax SLR 35mm Cameras 1952-1989 provides some guidance regarding which A series lenses were derived from earlier models.
“The SMC A lenses became very closely integrated with the SMC Pentax and SMC Pentax M lenses. Together they comprised the equipment for the bayonet mount Pentaxes in the years between 1983 and 1987. The arrival of a lens designed for the automatic exposure program did not always push the older generation lens out of the catalogue, but at the end of the Eighties, replacement was almost complete.”
Here are a few from Cecchi’s listings.
A 24mm/2.8 (SMC Pentax K 24/2.8)
A 28/2.8 (M 28/2.8)
A 35/2.8 (M 35/2.8)
A 35/2 (M 35/2)
A 50 versions 1.4, 1.7, 1.2 (SMC Pentax M)
A 100/2.8 (M 100/2.8)
A 135/2.8 an original design for A series
A 200/4 (SMC Pentax - I assume M series although he wasn’t clear)
A 15/3.5 (SMC K 15/3.5)
I browsed looking for information on lens coatings but there was little to be found save "all Super-Takumars between 1971-1975 benefitted from the multi-coating treatment." (Cecchi 96). There can be little doubt changes and improvements were made to SMC coatings over the years. Some of my M series lenses have a different colour cast to them than others. My M 35/2 has a sort of magenta cast which is quite different from my other M glass.
Source:
Cecchi, Daniel. Ashai Pentax and Pentax SLR 35mm Cameras 1952-1989. Hove, Sussex: Hove Foto Books, 1990. pp. 188-190.