Okay, I'm about to have an unexpected $150, maybe $200 to buy a new lens for my upcoming trip. I have about 4 lenses to consider and I'm looking for some guidance.
Current Situation
Pentax K-X (white)
Kit Lens
DA 50-200 f3.5
I'm pretty happy with the performance of the 50-200. For what I need it to do, it gets it done.
However, though the kit give me good results, I recently got to use the DA * 16-50/2.8 and an FA 50/1.8. That was quite the lens, and the increase in just quality of across the board spoiled me. I happened to be looking through the lens reviews and I noticed a couple of options that I think might get me halfway there.
Needs and Budget
I'm going to Provence, Nice & the French Riviera, Cinque Terre, and Florence at the end of June. The trip is the result of an amazing airmiles deal, and we're going on a shoestring.
Additionally, I just got a really cheap blackberry, and I'm selling my Android phone so I should net around $200. I pretty much HAVE to stay within that.
I'm not a pro, but recently shot a wedding as a favor (it came out great), and I would like to pick up some more amateur gigs. I rented the above-mentioned lenses for the wedding, and if I can pick up something now, that will prevent me from renting one or the other for my next gig, that would be another money savings. As part of my side business, I take some product shots for a company and put them on the website I run.
Interestingly, the last time I was in Europe (honeymoon), I had a Kodak DX7590 - which goes from 38-380, 35mm equivalent.
While I only took a handfull of shots above 250mm equiv, I was CONSTANTLY fighting not having a wider-angle lens. In cities, photographing architechture with narrow streets, etc. I was always backing up, and it was never enough. So I'm going to have to have SOME lens that goes down going down to 18 or below.
However, this isn't just about the trip. I rarely go below 28mm equiv in my day-to-day shooting at home.
So my needs for this lens are:
- Needs to be a marked improvement over my current glass
- Needs to be able to handle a large % of the shots I'll take on my trip
The Options
I've been scouring the reviews section, the marketplace, ebay, and KEH, and I have come up with 4 options that I think will work for me.
Option 1 - Marginal Kit Replacement Sigma 18-125 DC F3.5-5.6 Pentax Forums Rating: 9.0/6 reviews - - Price Range $175-200
Resulting Vacation Lens List:
- 18-125 (80% usage)
- 50-200 (20% usage)
Pro/Cons:
Pro: Extremely high ranking in reviews. Con: Those reviews do mention some indoor IQ issues. Photozone's review is fairly negative. Pro: Replaces my Kit lens and then some Con: On paper, it's not THAT much better than my kit lens Con: Might be fine, but then again, might not cut it for a paying gig. Essential Question: Does it improve on the kit lens enough to warrant an upgrade?
Option 2 - Replace It ALL Tamron 18-200 Di F3.5-5.6 Pentax Forums Rating: 8.25/4 reviews - - Price Range $200 used-300 new
Resulting Vacation Lens List:
- 18-200 (95% usage)
- 28mm MF Prime (5% usage)
Pro/Cons:
Pro: Very little switching on my trip. Would allow me to bring my nice MF primeCon: One review mentioned "terrible" AF performance. Pro: Replaces my kit lens for everyday use Con: Wouldn't cut it for a paying gig Pro: Gets high marks for IQ Con: I'm not a big fan of superzooms. Essential question: Does an entry level superzoom trump two entry level zooms of the same spec?
Option 3 - The Tweener Sigma 28-105 f2.8-4 Pentax Forums Rating: 7/3 reviews - - Price Range <$100
Resulting Vacation Lens List:
- 18-50 (15% usage)
- 28-105 (65% usage)
- 50-200 (20% usage)
Pro/Cons:
Pro: Cheapest lens here. Con: Everyone says its soft wide open, one review said the build quality was poor. Pro: F2.8 sounds like a good improvement on paper. Con: I'm going to be switching lenses all the time on my trip. Pro: If it was excellent, it would work for a wedding. Essential Question: Is this lens a hidden gem? Is it worth the $75 or so to find out?
Option 4 - Prime Lens out of Nowhere Pentax DA 35mm f2.4 Pentax Forums Rating: 9.31/14 reviews - - Price Range $175-200
Resulting Vacation Lens List:
- 18-50 (30% usage)
- 35 (30% usage)
- 50-200 (40% usage)
Pro/Cons:
Pro: Consistently adored by everyone. Con: Means switching lenses a lot on the trip. I'll be in a lot of open spaces that don't suit themselves to Prime shooting. Pro: I love shooting prime. Loved that 50/1.4 but would have liked it to be 35mm Con:It's kind of expensive for what amounts to a "bonus" lens for this trip. Pro: I will use it a ton at home. Con:It will be available much cheaper as it starts to come up used.
Finally, I am aware of the DA 16-45/f4 and how much love it gets around here, but it's way out of my . I've seen it go for around $250 used. Is it the answer? Should I suck it up, beg the wife, and post a WTB ad for one?
Last edited by Ryan Trevisol; 04-07-2011 at 07:48 PM.