I've hoarded 4 ultrawides
and thought I'd give them a kind of a rigorous test before letting some go. So today I took them out (forgot the Sigma 10-20/4.5 at home - damn!) and here are some initial impressions (with pics to follow).
at f8:
1. They are all decently sharp in the centre with Pentax having a slight edge.
2. In the corners Samyang's edge increases especially over the Sigma. DA is still pretty good.
3. CA especially present in Pentax and also in the Sigma, mostly blue fringing, it is practically absent on the Samyang.
4. Distortion is lowest on the Sigma, seems pretty good (I don't have such a great eye for it) on the DA and funny on the Samyang - some parts of the image are not distorted and some are significantly distorted.
Note that there was a compounding factor - the exposure times were not exactly the same.
at f13 there is not much between the lenses as Sigmas CA disappear. I guess distortions are same as above.
Last edited by DanielT74; 04-19-2011 at 06:08 AM.