Originally posted by JHD Sigma 10-20 vs. Pentax DA15.
If you like shooting at 10mm, there’s no way 15mm will ever serve as an adequate or satisfying substitute. So here's a little exercise you might want to try... take your Sigma 10-20 and set it at 15mm. Then go out and shoot lots of pictures and see if you can resist pulling back to 10mm........ If you can live within the confines of 15mm and not wish for a wider perspective, then you might be able to live with the DA15.
As a well-known DA15 hater, JHD is trying to trick you. It would be human nature to try and go wider, longer, faster, etc. when you can. A better test is to try a DA15 for a while, if it doesn't satisfy you, return it for a refund. It's not like all of us that had a 10-20 realized that we shot mostly at 15 so we just swapped it for a DA15. It's appeal is about more than just FL. It's just plain more enjoyable to shoot with (for pretty much everyone except JHD). Like many have said, it turns out that 15 is plenty wide most of the time.
Honestly, though, if you want to go with a bigger, wider lens, I would get a 8-16 over a 10-20. Make it worth the size/weight disadvantage to get something truly unique.