Originally posted by RonHendriks1966 Two tests from both lenses from the same tester:
...
Well that 28mm isn't so good I guess.
I would take this test with a BIG grain of salt. Apparently they got bad copies. All of the wide aperture sample shots are front focused. If the lens behaved as badly as they measured / experienced it, I would not have kept it.
I cannot speak to the lens' full frame performance but my copy must be a lot better than what they have tested.
I remember the LensTip test from when I was considering the lens and it nearly made me change my mind. However, I saw much better sample shots elsewhere and the lens came with a big recommendation by Peter Zack who has used it for wedding photography. He was full of praise for it. He might be using it still.