this is the final comparative test result that I have done with the FA35 and NX30 lens.
the interesting note about this last test is that I used one camera system for both lenses and see how would they perform on equal terms. the test was conducted using the NX100 at F2, ISO100 with shutterspeed around 1/160 or 1/200 set on a tripod. 2-sec timed shutter manually focused shot with multiple number of images at certain focus adjustments in order to get the best possible focused image from both lenses. distance shooting was done at MFD.
1st Image full-view comparison for bokeh, color, FOV, perceived sharpness.
FA35
NX30
personal evaluation: Bokeh are pretty much identical except that the FA35 has a slight narrowness in the DOF. both bokeh are pleasing for me personally and liked it. colors are both vibrant and appealing with the NX30 displaying a much better colour accuracy and rendering especially the magenta variation. the FOV difference is obvious and which is further magnified by the mount adapter length. both lens are sharp but the NX30 appear sharper in this respect.
center crops from the 1st image. difference in sharpness, contrast, detail
FA35
NX30
take note that the FA35 image here is downsized to match the exact NX30 image size. here we noticed the the NX30 display a bit more contrast, sharpness and detail elaboration.
2nd Image comparison. center crops. sharpness, detail and contrast assessment
FA35
NX30
same result
3rd Image comparison. center crops. sharpness, detail and contrast assessment
FA35
NX30
same result
now let's add some twist to see a more elaborate difference:
4th Image comparison. same parameter test except that the NX30 image is up-sized to match the FA35 image size.
FA35
NX30
even if the roles were reversed, the NX30 still display a much elaborate clearer and sharper image than the FA35 at it's normal resolution.
5th Image comparison. same parameter testing. this time, the contrast and sharpness value are set to "0".
FA35
NX30
this pretty much concludes everything.
final thoughts, the FA35 images seems much more respectably sharp apparently this time when used on the same camera system rather than on a different system for comparison, which we may think or conclude that has to do with the NX system having a more updated/better sensor or a different camera rendering of the parameters. however, upon comparing both images coming from both lenses now on one system, would now suggest the difference in performance between the two lenses and not just because of the camera system used. the difference are noticeable and clearly shows the advantage of one lens over the other. it could be that the coating, optical formula of the NX30 lens further enhanced it's performance over the FA35.
I didn't bother to show the images at midrange and infinity this time since the results are pretty much the same as before. as to the performance of the two lenses at similar other apertures, particularly at their strongest opening at F4, the NX30 is pretty much a marvel and the FA35 is pretty good as well (in the past, I would had said outstanding performance for the FA35).
Last edited by Pentaxor; 08-17-2011 at 08:22 PM.