Originally posted by dsimon I was discussing all of this with my wife, and talking about the prices, and she asked a question that I haven't been able to answer, so I turn to the forums. Would you rather have the DA14mm AND DA21mm lenses OR the DA12-24mm zoom? That is probably what my decision comes down to.
Dan
It is really hard to advise what is right for you.
I personally bought the sigma 10-20 and love it,
I have used it all through the range of focal lengths.
The real question, and you need to answer that is, Is 14mm wide enough, or do you want more.
As I said, I have used my sigma 10-20 through the entire range, and as a result, now that I have it, I woudl find 14mm somewhat limiting.
You need to try both the 12-24 and the 14mm, and think about it a little. In the end, no one other than you will know if you willbe happy with the two primes, or the zoom.
Consider the range of zoom, and the speed (or loss of with a zoom) and go for it.