Originally posted by Marc Sabatella But for someone who, after examining the Exif of their own photos as I have done for mine, finds they really do shoot telephoto more than wide angle (this would be rare), then indeed a 28-200 could make sense as a primary lens, I'll acknowledge.
That's really the biggest issue if you are going to take focal length into account is your shooting habits (cost might be an even bigger isue for some of us). a 18-55mm would be mostly useless (not saying there might not be some circumstances) for a wildlife shooters that shoots mostly birds. Something in the 300-500mm range might be better but that would be worthless to someone shooting people in confines spaces. Obviously lenses with greater range like 18-250mm or 50-500mm would server best as all around lenses for every circumstance but some of us can not afford them. 28-200's are very common with a lot of used ones floating around so they are available cheaper. Honestly I suspect that the wide availability of the older versions drive down the price of the newer versions too, especially with lenses like the tamron where there are several versions and not that good of information on how many there are, what the differences are etc. I haven't been buying and looking into buying 28-200mm lenses because I thought it was the best focal range. I have been doing it because its the best focal range for an all around lens that can be gotten on a tight budget.
On a side note, I rarely use my 18-55mm. I use 35-70, 28-70, 28-90 etc lenses all the time. Its rare that I have to have wider though there is the occasional instance where I back into a wall and wish I did have wider. When I have taken my 18-55mm its not occasional that I have wanted longer, its frequent but that is with my personal shooting habits.
Like magkelly said, if it is the newest version 60$ is a steal. For the older versions like the 271 and 571 its a decent enough price (I wouldn't pay much more as you would be getting into the range where you could get an ex or ex+ one from keh with a 6 month warranty). Bargain grade seem to go for 40-50$ on keh (remember to add shipping to that though). Those keh prices are for the older versions by the way.