I can see why toy might be having some doubts axl. The FA* is a strange and mythical beast
I have used the DA* 16-50 (so very disappointed) and Tammy and have owned the Sigma 17-50mm f2.8 EX DG OS HSM. I can honestly say that (IMO) if you want to go pixel peeping and if outright sharpness is your goal, the Sigma is probably the lens for you. Wide open it is very decent and stopped down it is INCREDIBLY sharp for a zoom. More can be read in
Photozones review of this lens. I ended up selling my copy of the Sigma as I was unhappy with its auto focus performance on the K7.
I bought my copy of the FA* 28-70 about 6 months ago and have only really just decided to keep it now. I don't get emotional about lenses all that often but FA* glass is something special and there is something very, very nice about the look of the pictures that you get from it.
When I bought my copy and probably paid to much there was a lot of emotion that went into the purchase.
BUT....
- The rotating front element is a pain!
- It is impossible not to mark the silver finish.
- Wide open its not as sharp as the others (stopped down its still not as sharp as the Sigma).
- There are issues with CA and PF (most of which can easily be corrected in camera raw).
- Its HEAVY (I walked about 10km with it the other day and it did get a bit tedious).
- Auto focus is noisy.
Even with all of those issues though I still really enjoy owning this lens. Whilst the Sigma was a great lens it just took photos. If posted on line no one would ever pick which lens was used to shoot them. The FA* on the other hand seems to produces images with a unique fingerprint, very much like the way my FA* 24mm does.
- I love the colours and the contrast it produces.
- The softness wide open can be a big deal but I think it works very nicely for portraits (my girlfriend looks so much better at f2.8
).
- The bokeh is the best I have experienced from any zoom I have used in this focal length.
- Stopped down for landscape stuff it is an excellent performer.
- Whilst noisy, the auto focus (at least on my copy) is blisteringly fast and now I have it dialled in with a little bit of micro adjustment is very accurate.
- I also love the confused looks I get from some Canikon users (a man toting a large beige lens at the zoo the other day couldn't stop peering out the corner of his eye trying to figure out exactly what I had in my hand
)
The Pentaxian in me also enjoys owning a piece of pentax history.
I can see why this lens might not be for every body and I can see how some people might consider it over priced but for these reasons outlined above and the FA* 28-70 suits me just fine.
A quick happy snap from last weekend
K7 - FA*28-70 @28mm - f11 - 1/100 - ISO100