Originally posted by creampuff Can there any doubt... the DA* 50-135 is the one you should definitely go for.
The 10-17mm fisheye does offer a unique take on things but ask yourself this question, which lens is more versatile and more likely to be used? How many fisheye images do you see posted? Lots of people let go of their FE after the novelty wears off.
I don't post on this forum because I used my posting limit on lens reviews, but I post plenty FE elsewhere :-) And, at 17mm it has only very slight fisheye. It's my favorite lens and I find it indispensible at museums...
Of course, it depends entirely on what you want to shoot, and how.