Originally posted by K-rrr Funnily enough I just remembered I had a set of old extension tubes I hadn't touched for around 20 years. I attached a Pentax M 50mm 1.7 and had a go. Pretty decent results I thought, though focussing at such close distances was a first for me and pretty challenging. I found focussing was best achieved by moving the camera, rather than focussing the lens itself. I would imagine a bellows set up would help this process.
The hardcore use bellows with both standards movable, and a focusing rail under the subject and/or bellows for precise positioning. The bellows itself sets the magnification, with DOF control if the standard(s) will tilt-shift. The focusing rail sets the focus distance.
Quote: One thing I am curious about is why an enlarger lens is often recommended for this, rather than a standard prime. Is it to do with achieving edge to edge sharpness cheaply (many cheap old primes have no problems stopped down), portability, or something else entirely?
That's most of the answer. ELs are designed for edge-to-edge flatfield sharpness, and optimized for close work. Some ELs are highly prized for their superb optics and are NOT cheap -- you'll find some on eBay in the US$1k+ region. But even cheap ELs can give outstanding results. I've bought name-brand (Schneider, Rodenstock, etc) ELs at four for US$10 shipped. Our resident master here is
yeatzee who prefers an EL-Nikkor 50/2.8. Mine was free, sent as a bonus, but it's usually under US$25. Its slightly inferior f/4 brother cost me FIVE BUCKS shipped. (And I've sold EL-Nikkor crystal cases for US$20 each -- no lens, just the case. Some folks are nutz.) But some of my favorites, labeled Vivitar-LU or Ilex or Apos or Wollensak or Eastman, cost under US$5 each, shipped. Cheap thrills!
Some lenses were designed for dual use, for both taking and projecting. Leica used to market their Elmars as such (long long ago). I have a Leitz Varob 50/3.5 (US$19 shipped) that's essentially an Elmar without the focusing helicoid. Steinheil, who invented some of our basic optical technology, has a series of VL lenses that can either be mounted on focusing tubes, or removed and placed on an enlarger. I use the Culminar VL 105/4.5 and 135/4.5 (each US$20 shipped). Still, most ELs work best close. Don't forget to use a hood when possible. Hint: a macro tube makes a good hood on a reversed lens.