Originally posted by ComputerControlled I initially assumed that all the new lenses made for DSLRs had this crop factor built into the lenses.
Crop factor is way of comparing the field of view created by a lens on two different cameras. But it does not and cannot ever change the actual focal length of the lens. All 50mm lenses produce exactly the same field of view *when used on the same camera*. But the same 50mm lens will produce an entirely different FOV on your MX versus on your K100D.
In short - crop factors are ocassionally useful for comparing the same lens pn different *cameras*, but they have nothing to do with comparing different *lenses*.
Quote: So a 35mm lens made for a DSLR would actually be 35mm.
And so it is. Again, all 35mm lenses - whether new or old, manual or AF, made fo film or digital - have *exactly* the same focal length, and hence they have *exactly* the same FOV when used on any given camera.
Quote: That makes more sense to me, to show what equivalent size is on the lens.
that makes no sense whatsoever. A lens has no idea what type of camera it is goong to be mounted to. again, any given 35mm lens has an entirely different FOV depending on what *camera* it is mounted to, but all 35mm lenses have the same FOV pn any one given camera. If they are going to go around putting crop factors on anything, it could only be on cameras, not on lenses, because again, crop factors are only useful as a means of comparing cameras, not of comparing lenses.
Quote: Rather than make people guess.
there is no guesswork. Again, all 35mm lenses - digital or film, manaul or AF, Pentax or Sigma, black or silver, macro or non-macro, meta or plastic - they all have the exact same FOV on your K100DS. If you are wondering what focal length lens would produce the same FOV on your MX, you multiply by the crop factor *for the K100DS*, and again, you do this exactly the same way regardless of what 35mm lens you are talking about. there is nothing that could be possibly be written on the lens, or done to the lens, or changed about how the lens is described, that changes this.
Quote: AFAIK, all 50mm lenses will look the same on any SLR.
On any *one* SLR, yes. But a 50mm lens mounted to your MX has an entirely different FOV than that same 50mm mointed to your K100D.