Originally posted by Anvh * SDM is SDM, an ultrasonic motor, why won't volkswagen come with a diesel version 2 motor?
Volkswagen (and everyone else) has been improving diesels for a century. As you say, Sigma uses "ring type for most, same as canon for their high end lenses" but these are still ultrasonic motors, right? SDM is SDM, but SDM
is not USM or HSM or SWM. Same technology, different implementation and designs.
The point is not that the type of motor should change (ultrasonic), but the design of it (Pentax's SDM, as seen in the DA*16-50mm). Who knows, maybe the DA*60-250mm and more recent 16-50's use an "improved design" of the same technology but are still called SDM. Some seem to think that the whole issue of reliability was resolved long ago...
My only gripe about SDM is that it is dog-slow compared to the Canon ring-type USM I had on my old "L" lenses, and the HSM on my recent Sigma. I know every lensmaker has AF motors fail sometimes, while my DA*50-135mm has been problem-free for 5 years, but it's not getting any faster with age.