Good Evening, From my view, you have a number of options here between the Zeiss / Pentax family of lenses. Overall, it is going to be difficult to really make a bad decision. Its all up to what you want and what you want to spend. Across the available focal lengths, you have to choose from are the 28 and 25mm, in terms of something less than your current 35mm. You also have somewhat of a choice of apertures either f2 or f2.8. You could go wider than 25mm, however both the 21 and 18mm lenses are extremely expensive.
- 31mm - You can't go wrong with this lens. Sharp center, autofocus, it does everything.
- 28mm - You have a couple of choices here, the "recently" discontinued Zeiss 28 f2 ZK or the 10 to 30 year old Contax Zeiss 28mm f2.8 or the Contax Zeiss 28mm f2.0 lenses. The Zeiss was discontinued about 18 months ago or so, while the Contax Zeiss was discontinued in 2005 (however production started in 1985). The Contax 28/f2 is famous - called the Hollywood lens since it is well liked for video and it is reasonably expensive. The real sleeper is the Contax 28/f2.8, which is an excellent lens and can be acquired pretty reasonably. The Contax lenses need to have their mounts changed using parts from Leitax.com. Also, the Pentax K28/f2 is the same optical design as the Contax 28mm f2 lens (or the "Hollywood" lens that has somewhat of a cult following with the Canon folks).
- 25mm - Pretty much the same story as the 28mm, however there is only a single Contax lens at f2.8 available.
Here is a "shootout" between the Pentax 31 Ltd and the Contax 28mm/f2.8
Here are a number of links to the Forum's lens data base for the Zeiss lenses, and a number of individual lenses reviewed.
A little over a month ago I acquired a Zeiss 25/f2.8 and I have 2 Contax lenses that I converted over the last couple of years. The 28/2.8 and the 85/2.8. I also have the FA 31 Ltd lens. To compare and contrast the Zeiss vs the Contax can be summed up as size and weight. The newer Zeiss ZK are absolutely beautifully made. You will never find a better made lens, however they are heavy from the all metal and glass material. Their construction is equivalent to the old Pentax Takumar lenses. The Contax lenses - actually comparing the 28mm via some reviews, are wonderful optically. Their construction mirrors the FA Limited series.
The one major difference is the newer Zeiss ZKs to close focus and their incrediable large focus throw (on the 25mm ZK its about 350 of a 360 degree complete turn). 180 degrees of which is focusing between 6 and 12 inches. The Contax lenses do not provide this wide focus throw nor the close focus capability.
A quick note here, Contax is the camera brand of Zeiss and Zeiss made all their lenses (in the later years they were made in Japan under license).
Also, here is a long running thread on Zeiss lenses.
Last edited by interested_observer; 05-23-2012 at 10:15 PM.