Originally posted by Isnwm Pentax A50mm/2.0
This is an OK lens but for natural light in a church the f/1.4 would be better. The problem with these lenses is that wide open the depth of focus is extremely small, sometimes only an inch or so. An inexperienced photographer in low light with lens @ f/2 is not going to turn out well. Manual focus takes a lot of practice to get right especially at wide open apertures. The slightest bit off and you miss the shot.
Originally posted by Isnwm Anything shot in the church was dark, and not good.
This is an exposure problem, not a lens problem. The f/2 is capable of taking pictures in almost complete darkness, (on a tripod), with the right settings. What mode did you have the camera set on? Post a couple of pictures with the EXIF intact and we can take a look.
Originally posted by Isnwm What amazed me was how FAST his focus was.
Canon is generally respected as having a very fast auto-focus system at least in its upper end models. However, I have seen studies showing that Pentax (at least the k-5) is more consistently accurate, just not as fast.
Originally posted by Isnwm I'm kinda looking at the sigma 24-70 f/2.8, but wasn't sure if anyone could recommend for or against it ?
Here is the
link to the review section on that lens. I do not have it, so I cannot speak to the quality. For weddings I would go with at least a two lens kit, one lens in the 17-50 range to cover the wide end and then something in the 50-135 or 200 range to get the long shots. In crowded receptions the 24mm is not going to be wide enough on aps-c.
Originally posted by Isnwm I know a lot of that has to do with the iso, and his flash,
Correct, and also his experience. You could do the same with your k-5 and a good lens and flash. Don't be overawed by what you saw, he gets paid to do that so it had better work. Put a good flash and say the Pentax*16-50 on your k-5 and you could do the same or close enough that no one could tell.
Originally posted by Isnwm It was ugly. Real ugly.
I suspect this has more to do with your experience level than the gear. You should be able to get very good quality images with the k-5 and the kit lens when using a flash if everything is set up properly. The key is practice and experimenting. I came away from some early shoots, a couple friends weddings like yourself, wondering why I had spent all this money on gear when my wife's P&S camera took better pictures. But you can improve, and you must remember it is not the gear, it is the photographer. People shot great images with fully manual cameras for many years because they studied, practiced and made the gear work.