Well, I went out based on Hins recommendations and purchased a promaster 1.7tc...My results are similar to others.
The good,
It's image quality is better than the 2 kenkos I have and far better than any 2X TC i have...It's priced right. I paid less than 80 bucks for mine.
The bad,
It's image quality, does not compare to the Tamron 1.4tc or the Pentax 1.7tc,
It does not work with HSM, it is very slow to auto focus and with this TC, I have quite a few missed shots...
The ugly,
I was using in on a sigma 135-400 F/5.6 LENS...a great lens on its own and with the Tamron 1.4tc, the extra half stop it lost, really hurt it.
The pretty,
It did very well considering It lost 1.5 stops...I know when I stick it onto my fast lenses, (F/2.8 and F/4.0) It will kick butt...
Anyway, here are some samples. Aside from resizing, NO PP work done. They are as they came out of the camera, roughly 100 YARDS AWAY....
Here is 230mm
Here is 680mm
All are hand held with shake reduction on K10D.