I have been on some serious LBA here lately. I have bought a ton of lenses but I am still lacking one (irony I know)...
Actually I am lacking more than one
I have looked at almost all the lenses that I can think of that are auto focus 50mm... and at least according to the reviews the FA 50mm f1.7 is the best of them all. As to the ratings here it out does all the competition.
All the other 50mm lenses are rated lower than this lens, even the lenses that cost substantially more or that have larger apertures. I have a manual f1.4 but I am just now getting the hang of shooting with that one...
I want to get an AF fast prime lens and so far the FA 50mm f1.7 is the clear winner as to the reviews here...but is there any real reason to even consider the DA 50mm f1.8? Or even the 55mm f1.4?
On the latter I am not sure if I even want to mess with SDM which I assume does not use the camera's internal focusing screw drive. From what I hear it is less reliable than the screw drive...
Aside from the obvious price difference (which is major) why would I even consider the 55mm? I could probably buy it eventually, but I don't shoot in the rain, being weather sealed makes little or no difference for me...
I have seen the prime lens shootout but it still leaves wide open the question as to which lens of this nature is superior. It looks to me as though the FA model is where its happening. I am shying away from the DA 50mm f1.8. I would like to have a brand new DA lens, but I would rather have a used one that is tried, true, and proven to be good. For roughly the same or even a little cheaper I can get something that is top notch.
Pentax 50mm Prime Lens Shootout - Introduction - PentaxForums.com
What if any is the downside to the FA 50mm f1.7? Why would I even want to mess with these other lenses when that one is out there floating around? Including the f1.4 version...
Last edited by alamo5000; 12-24-2012 at 04:20 PM.