If I look at my current kit, compared to the OP
Originally posted by tabl10s For me, no:
Soligor,
Osawa
Quantaray
Sears
J.C. Penney
Chinon
I don't have any of the above
Quote: Russian
this would exclude my Helios 58/2 and zenitar 16/2.8 FE
Quote: Chinese
I don't have any chinese, except the Nikon and Canon infinity focus corrected to PK adaptors,
Quote: Vivitar(current)
if you consider all samyang varients, this excludes my 8mm fe, 13/2.8 and 85/1.4
Quote: Pro-MC
Kenko
I don't have any of the above
Quote: Screw-mount
excluding the 2 russian lenses above, this also excludes my tamron 24/2.5, vivitar 28/2.5, SMC Tak 35/2, super tak (8 element version 50/1.4, SMC Macro Tak 50/4, SMC Tak 55/1.8 super tak 85/1.9, 105/2.8 vernon edonar preset, tamron 90mm F2.5 macro, tele lentar 135/2.8 preset, smc tak 135/3.5, takumar 200/3.5 preset, smc tak 200/4, and Nikkor H 300/4.5 converted to screw mount
Quote: If it ain't Tamron/Sigma/Tokina/Pentax, "nuttin doin!"(who came up with that phrase?).
so based upon the bottom line, this excludes 19 lenses of my kit
in fact when you look at this type of approach, ok fine, but there appears to be a lack of understanding regarding some of the lenses excluded. even the new vivitar aka samyang lenses offer excellent optical quality and performance far superior to some tamron, sigma and tokina lenses that are out there. looks more like brand snobbery to me than realistic thinking.
About the only lenses I absolutely will not by are the takumar based 500 and 1000mm lenses because with MFD of between 50 and 100 feet, they are useless to me.