Originally posted by jpzk Same here: totally spoiled with the DA*300/4 IQ and that's probably why I "want" something in a longer FL with the same quality ... another wish.
What TC do you use with your 300mm lens(es)?
Looks like the options are: Sigma 300/2.8 with a great TC to match it, and not loose in IQ, and perhaps a Tamron Adaptall that someone suggested to me . ?
Still hoping for the ghostly Pentax SDM 1.4X (with the DA*300/4).
As far as a TC for my 300mm lens, right now I am in a very fortunate position owning both an FA*300 4.5 and a DA*300. I am in the process of a serious comparison of both lenses since I can't afford to keep both. I have not tried any TC's on the DA*300, But did try the Tamron 1.4x TC briefly on the FA*300. What I found with the combination was the the IQ was nearly identical with the TC installed vs. cropping the native image to equal that of the TC. So with that knowledge, I sold the TC since I could get the same results by simply cropping. But.....I've been given the opportunity to try a TC again on the FA*300 - the Vivitar 1.4x. The Vivitar is only screw drive so the testing will again be on the FA*300. As far as the TC with the DA*300 I sold the TC before I aquired the DA*.
As far as the Tamron Adaptall 300mm 2.8, that with the Pentax AF 1.7x TC was a very good combo. I am not good at all with manual focusing, so the auto-focus TC was a must for me. But, at the end of the day, the IQ of that lens with the TC did not equal that of the FA*300.
I have to agree with you that I think in both of our cases, the hopeful Pentax SDM TC with the DA*300 might be the killer combo. I have also considered the Sigma 300mm 2.8 + TC, but we are getting into high price territory again.
So for me, it has come down to getting closer somehow, or to pony up the big bucks for the Sigma 300 2.8 + TC or 500 4.5. In my present position that is not going to happen.
In the meantime I will give the FA*300 and Vivitar 1.4x TC a prudent evaluation. I'm almost afraid that it might work very well for me then the decision will have to be made to sell the DA* which I don't really want to do...........
And I apologize for taking your thread off your main question about the Bigma and 150-500. Myself, I am going either of the routes I mentioned above. But, between Larry (crewl1) and GaryH's results with the newer Bigma, that temptation is still there somewhat. But I've already spent so much money and time with all my experimental lenses, I'm to the point of working with what I have, or "go big or go home".