I'm also in the 17-70 club and I like it a lot too.
I've still got my 18-55, but I'm not sure if I'm going to hang on to it or get rid of it. At this point, for what I do, I don't think that I need to go any wider than 17, so I'm pretty happy.
If you're interested in the 28-75 and don't need to go as wide as the 12-24 or 10-20, but would still like another lens that's a little wider, then something in the 17 to 20-35 range might work. Since these lenses were designed more for film, there aren't too many new ones available anymore, but you may be able to pick one up used reasonably through Fleabay or KEH.
At one point, I was thinking about doing the 28-75 + wider prime or zoom combination, but it would've put more of a strain on my budget than I was comfortable with, so that was one of the things that pushed me towards the 17-70. Another thing was that for me, it made more sense to carry around only 1 lens that could do it all versus 2 lenses that covered basically the same range.
Ultimately, it boils down to 2 questions--budget and space in the camera bag.
HTH,
Heather