Originally posted by K57XR What happened to the DA18-135WR - didn't make the list?
Top performing Pentax lenses that they didn't test.
Tamron 17-50, 90 Macro,
Sigma 8-16, 70-200, 70 macro- 105 macro, 85 1.4, 300, 500
Pentax 31, 43 and 77 limited, DA 18-135, DA* 200, DA* 300, and a whole host of legacy glass.
16 of arguably the best lenses available for Pentax were not tested. Throw in the Samyang lenses which are top rated on DxO on every system they test on, but not tested on Pentax at all, and you could make a case that the best 20 lenses available for K-mount aren't even included in their list. I seriously question the compiler of this list, and once again warn people not to pay any attention to DxO until you've done enough reading on the site to understand their biases and omissions. It's not that their information is useless. It's that you really have to pay attention to understand what it means.
Personally I won't take them seriously until I see the Sigma 70, 85, 105 and 70-200, Tamron 17-50, 24-70 and 90 macro, all Samyangs, and the 18-135, 60-250 , 200 and 300 tested on their site on K-mount. You simply cannot take a site seriously that tests all those lenses (but the DA lenses) on Canon and Nikon, but not on Pentax. They have a serious anti- Pentax bias in their research. They are a private company and it's all market driven, and Pentax has really small market share, I understand that, but fair is fair. My advice to them with regard to Pentax would be walk the walk, or shut up.
Unless what Pentax users were supposed to get from that would be that the Sigma 35 1.4 is a really good lens. How does it stack up against the FA 31? DxO doesn't know, even though they try and sound like "experts".
Quote: Admittedly, I don't put much stock into what DXOmark says. But per their methods, the lenses that they list make sense. And if a lens isn't on Pentax mount, just select the Nikon D7000 and you'll see the relative performance.
Not exactly...
The 35 1.4 tests 4 points lower on a K-5 than it does on a D7000, even though the K5 has a higher sensor rating (go figure). DxO numbers are pretty inconsistent comparing different brands... they really only make sense comparing the same body