Originally posted by yellowbrick I am enjoying my K-01 with the DA limited lenses 15, 21, 40, and 70mm. But sometimes I want to have the convenience of a short zoom for times when I don't want or can't change lenses easily. Because I'm using the K-01, I want a very light and compact zoom lens, so I'm ruling out the 17-70s, 17-50s, 18-250s, and even (for the moment) the 18-135. Which leaves me with the cheap (always welcome) and light kit lens 18-55 (either DA-L or WR versions) or maybe the F 35-70 of which I've read excellent reviews and see for sale at very good prices. Actually, both these options are about the same price used. I know the DA kit lens is more of a walkaround lens with the wider field of view but I really like to shoot in the 40-70mm range, so maxing out at 55mm may not be ideal, plus I've read that the 18-55 is weakest at the long end. If I went for the F 35-70, I could easily carry around the 21mm for the occasional need to go wide on a walkabout with my camera.
So if anyone has experience using both the 18-55 kit lens (DA-L, ver II, or WR models), and the smc-F 35-70mm, particularly on the K-01, could you chime in on which one is a better performer: (1) optically (sharpness, colors, flare resistance), and (2) mechanically (autofocus speed, build quality). I'm probably leaning towards the 35-70 based on user reviews that rave about it, but I think the 18-55 could also be good, especially since it's a newer design, optimized for digital, and has modern lens coating.
Thanks for any comments and suggestions!
IMO the two lenses are basically the same on optical performance. I owned both, and here is my opinion:
1855: get the 2nd gen one (not WR cuz it's kind expensive, not L cuz it's bad). Usually you can get this around $50~$70 from ebay or KEH;
F35-70: on the APS-C it's like 50-105 (weirdly it's common huh). And here is the photos:
http://pp.163.com/johnyoker/pp/7926035.html#29083319
The biggest different is the focus length. Optically F35-70 will suffer a little bit from purple fringe. However it is pretty compact, and focuses very quick. (in a violent way=kinda noisy).
1855: I used to own 1855WR and then sold it for DA15, and then I got a 1855 II back and then sold it...now I bought it back again (sigh) with 50-200 and I will keep both lens forever and ever. I think if you want to get 1855, get 50200 as well cuz they are just so small. 1855 is fine, however some aberration at corner (soft), that's the only problem.