Originally posted by Rondec Do you really think that? "Sensor size determines NOTHING?" Obviously on a k mount camera, with the same register distance, there will be limitations to the size of the lens, but certainly for a DA 70 limited to be full frame compatible, it would have to be bigger than it currently is. Same with the DA 40 and the DA 35 limiteds.
I beg to differ - the DA 70 probably needs a minor tweak to be full frame compatible at a decent quality across the frame (I use mine with film cameras)... and the DA 40 is based on the film version of the same and covers a full frame fine.
Leaving aside plastics and screw drives etc, the old manual focus Pentax lenses are small, like the old manual focus Olympus Zuikos, and do a fine job covering the full frame. With modern plastics etc the af versions don't need to be much larger, and will weigh less.
We have to look at history and the marketplace to see where size became a major (market) consideration. Nikon and then Canon prioritized ruggedness and performance over many other considerations, for the pro market. The other manufacturers went along - riding on the size = rugged idea, plus manufacturing/design cost -- making things the size they turned out to be I would think is cheaper than going for size reductions, especially where the raw material cost was less important than manufacture tolerance etc. Perhaps larger glass elements made lens design a bit easier also, as one could 'throw out' the edges...
But Pentax (and in the early days, perhaps Miranda) went against the grain, already with their earliest SLRs. The vision was portability and gracefulness, a la Leica, for the practial amateur. In the M42 days, often the Takumar is the smallest in any given category.
Olympus in the early 70s changed the market. Everyone got on the smaller size bandwagon -- even Nikon offered smaller cameras and lenses for the amateur market. Olympus for a while had the pro cachet as well working for them.
In the long run, it has turned out the pro connection is the strongest marketing force in quality SLRs. Thus, despite periodic downsizing for the amateurs (which Canikon is again doing) it is the large 'professional' cameras that sit at the top of the pile.