Afternoon,
Well, I do landscapes, cityscapes and architecture. I have had the DA 12-24 for 4 years now and am very happy. It is sharpest at 18mm and falls off some to the 24 mm end (they all do). The DA 16-45 is sharper at 24mm than the 12-24 (which stands to reason). Does it make a difference and do I worry about it. To me, not really. I have an image (from the 12-24 @ 24) that I printed at 20" x 30" and it blows everyone away that sees it (and it was handheld very late afternoon, early evening, right at sunset - with a lot of detail at the bottom corners). Is a prime better? Yes.
I choose the 12-24 because - not being as wide as the others, the distortion was a bit better controlled. In use does that matter? It depends on the shot, the subject matter, the framing and the perspective. I also liked Pentax's color, rendering and character.
The bottom line is - it really isn't going to matter that much. What ever your choice - some shots accentuate its strengths, while other shots will highlight its weakness. I have seen shots from all of them and there are outstanding shots from all of them. There are also shots from each, that if you look close enough you can find something to complain about. As far as color, rendering and character, I also have a Sigma 8-16 and its color, rendering and character are fantastic too.
Bottom line - go with what you can afford and everything will turn out alright. Another poster here on the Forum has the Tamron 10-24 and he was very happy with it - Rico.
Originally posted by RioRico My normal AF kit on my K20D are the DA10-17 fisheye (FE) zoom, Tamron 10-24 ultrawide (UWA) zoom, and DA18-250 superzoom. The FE and UWA complement each other; they don't overlap. ...<snip>
An ultrawide is a totally different tool than a fisheye. Not all ultrawides are equal. About 18 months ago I had the budget to buy any of the leading UWAs: DA12-24, Tamron 10-24, or either Sigma 10-20. I chose the Tamron because of its very useful focal range, its lower price and longer warranty, and known QC problems with the Sigmas. I recommend the Tamron.
It appears that Rico lost all of his likes for some reason?