Originally posted by OldNoob Just noticing how similar the DL limited and the HD lenses look in design, yet with a bit of a price difference. Evidently it has something to do with the coatings but Will they truly have better definition? Any experience in this area yet?
The updates include both new coatings and rounded aperture blades on all lenses involved. I can't speak to the specific nature of the "HD nano coating" - while I completely trust the explanation that there are subtle or profound differences in the various Pentax coatings (super-protect, ghostless, the well known SMC, etc.) rather than just being marketing hype, I don't pretend to know exactly how lenses benefit from a specific technology. Bojidar Dimitrov's Pentax K-Mount Page has
a page which might be insightful, although he has not yet updated the site to included information about the HD coating. I seem to recall a Pentax exec saying in an interview the HD coating was developed as an improvement over a previous formula which, as good as it was to fight flare and the like, it wasn't as tough as they would have liked.
As for the rounded aperture blades, the conventional wisdom is that rounded blades mean a more pleasant bokeh with smoother transitions and round, disc-shaped highlights (although I believe I've heard the number of elements or optical formula in a lens has a big impact on bokeh, as well). I'd be happy to hear any other contributions to the benefits of round blades, if there are any. A few sights like Photozone.de will occasionally remark on the shape of highlights with round or geometric shapes, although its rarely a deal breaker. Usually, the emphasis is more on how "rough" or "nervous" the bokeh can be.
Beyond the coating and aperture blades, the HD lens designs appear to be the same as their predecessors. I can't imagine the differently shaped blades would require anything different about the construction besides the blade parts themselves. For what it's worth, I'm curious to see how the ultra-wide-angle HD Pentax-DA 15mm F4 ED AL Limited tests. For a while I was gunning to get one of the original designs, however some sample shots betray corners that were a bit too soft for my liking. That being said, I've seen some fabulous images taken with the 15mm, and that lens has many enthusiastic fans. I don't expect the sharpness performance to change for the HD Pentax-DA 15mm F4, but maybe I'll be surprised. Likewise, the original version of the DA 70mm 2.4 is already crazy good; how much better could it get?!