Originally posted by ftpaddict You can take portrait shots with anything that can blur out the background, to separate your subject from everything else.
You can, but the perspective distortion from focal lengths ~<85mm will create funny faces. The nearer you are, the more the face will become a caricature of itself. You are almost getting away with the effect on your second shot, but it is noticeable and not many women would be happy with it.
Originally posted by benjikan R U kidding?
Not any more so than the multitude of sources that see the classic portrait focal length range ~ between 85mm and 135mm.
Originally posted by benjikan It is the perfect focal length for portraiture in my humble opinion.
I'm not going to argue with an accomplished, talented and professional artist as you are, but perhaps you have that opinion because you are going for certain effects. In your sample shot, her forehead is too pronounced to look natural. Her eyes are enlarged and her mouth appears to be smaller. That's fine for art, but if someone ordered a flattering portrait, I think they'd be expecting something less distorted.
I love your image with which you started this thread but I think part of the reason it works, despite the slightly too short FL, is because of the large shadow area (avoiding distortion of nearer parts of her face).
Anyone arguing that portraits taken with longer FLs are boring, that's fine with me, yet this doesn't invalidate the fact that the closer you get, the more you have to incorporate distortion as part of the message or artistic impression.