Originally posted by j2photos I know this question has been asked tons of times and I have read some of the threads but I want to list the lenses I am looking at and maybe you folks can steer me in the correct direction. I want a lens that will be my primary ultra wide that I will use for landscapes mainly but can use it for other things as well. I have also read the in depth reviews and the gear database. Unfortunately those seem to further confuse me because it does not seem I can go wrong with any of my choices.
Lenses I am looking to buy in the next two weeks.
Pentax DA 12-24
Sigma 10-20 3.5
DA limited 15mm
DA limited 20-40
Tamron 17-50 (owned this lens in the past)
Or maybe there is a suggestion of a lens that I am not looking at? Thanks for the advice in advance!
The SMC DA 15 is probably my most used lens, a true gem. Great for landscapes, especially with a foreground object to add interest and plenty of depth of field. And it does great blue skies. Highly recommended. You may be able to get a good deal on the SMC version at the moment, since the HD "upgrade" is still very new. There is a common feeling that, of the DA Limiteds recently refreshed with HD and rounded blades, only the 15 mm SMC version is actually more desirable than its HD counterpart. This is because the SMC doesn't flare, even when shooting directly into the Sun, making HD partially redundant, and because it's non-rounded blades deliver more beautiful diffraction stars.
I spent a long time thinking about the DA 12-24, but ultimately have decided to wait to see what its apparent replacement will be like. The Pentax Lens Roadmap has a ~12-28 (as far as can be judged from the green band) indicated for 2014 release. The DA 12-24 is highly regarded, apart from its fairly prominent CA.
I can't make up my mind about the DA 20-40. Very contradictory reports. However, even if it's a great lens, I wouldn't want it as a replacement for the DA 15. That extra 5mm makes all the difference for dramatic landscapes.