Originally posted by Adam Grunseth There have been some really good points made here, so here is what I am thinking now- I am going to really stretch my budget and live very frugally for the next couple months. I think I should be able to swing the Tamron 17-50mm f/2.8 XR Di-II LD new and a used DA L 55-300mm from eBay.
Not getting gored is a good thing. I do have my rain cover that I used with my K100D, though having a full WR system would be nice, I would rather put up with the rain cover and have the highest possible IQ.
You could even get the Tamron used if you like.
None of these lenses are expensive enough that you should spend much time fretting about whether they'll get damaged without WR. Just cover them up, as you said. They may represent your whole budget for now, but it's clear (from your descriptions of the IQ you like in lenses you've already used) that soon enough you'll be looking at 2-5 lenses in the $400-1200 range.
And actually the Tamron could become the first of these lenses. You could add a couple of other lenses to it later - possibly even a couple of inexpensive primes. Eventually you'll upgrade the DA L 55-300 to something better, but it's pretty good for the first year or so (and some people keep it much longer anyway).