when I started shopping for a premium, fast, AF 50mm lens, I knew that the new D FA* (the Fat Fifty) was not going to be anywhere near my self-imposed budget, so that left really only two lenses in consideration: the DA* 55/1.4 and the Sigma 50/1.4 EX DG...
the question about SDM reliability entered into the consideration, and while the DA* seems to be less likely to succumb to SDM failure, it is still a black-mark against the lens.... I don't think I've ever read an instance of HSM failure from any of the Sigma lenses...
I also knew that I would probably be buying used, mainly because new prices for DA* 55/1.4's were still beyond me, and there isn't another fast 50ish lens being manufactured by anyone else...
so I bought a Sigma 50/1.4 from the marketplace here....
just wow - it's my first HSM lens; I'm surprised by the speed and silence of it...