Originally posted by dcshooter
No surprises here. The 70-210mm is a great lens but is often overlooked and undervalued due to its being overshadowed by its "celebrity" 35-105mm sibling. It's also unfairly maligned here due to its low composite score (7) on its database rating that stems almost entirely from low handling scores from users not used to one touch manual zooms.
Originally posted by PKMike
I agree. I owned both, but owned the 70-210 as my first zoom, thereby learning on a "one touch". When I later obtained the 35-105 I found it both more cumbersome and time consuming to use. I never really viewed the 35-105 as superior to the 70-210. They are both solid performers in my opinion. I still have the 70-210, and agree that it is both underrated and under valued.
And I agree as well.
My first zoom (in 1980 or so) was a VS1 70-210/3.5 (Tokina V.2) in K-mount, and my next zoom (and my first Ka lens) was the A 70-210/4, so I "cut my zoom teeth" on one-touch zooms. Later on, when my first two-touch zooms became the A 35-105/3.5 and the A 28-135/4, I found the two-touch operation, at first, less than intuitive (although it did not take too long to become able to work with either system). In any event, I always thought the A 70-210/4 to be a ~very~ good lens, and I still have one here (although not the original copy, which eventually succumbed to too many rough and soggy whale watch trips over time, as did the VS1 70-210/3.5 before it).
I guess I'm still an "SMC Pentax A 70-210/4 Proud Owner", too...