Originally posted by gnaztee Thought I had this figured out with a travel set up of:
After a two-week trip to the East Coast, numerous lens changes, and equally numerous eye-rolls and heavy sighs from my wife while waiting for these lens changes, I've decided to go the zoom route
Todd
You're lucky you got off so easily.... On our last trip, I insisted on testing my 4 DA ltds. against the 3 FA ltds, against 5 zooms. My wife got mad at me for losing her voice for sighing so often and loudly. But I got some interesting shots of her being annoyed which the future kid will appreciate some day.
I discovered that the DA*50-135 was as good as my DA70 ltd. I also discovered that it was a bit short on the tele end.
I discovered that the DA*16-50 was almost as good but not as good as the DA40 at 40, but was closer to the DA21 at 21 than I thought it would be. Overall (and I got a good copy) The DA*16-50 performed better than I thought.
I found that I liked the DA*16-50 better than the Tamron 17-50, I liked the Tamron 28-75 better than the Tamron 17-50, and I liked the Sigma 24-60 EX 2.8 better than them all.
I almost went with keeping the Sigma 24-60 and adding the Pentax 12-24 to it and that would have been the best IQ for me.
But I went with convenience and sold all and kept the DA*16-50 as for me, that was wide enough, and it fit nicely with the 50-135.
If it were now or a month from now, I'd seriously be tempted by the DA17-70 along side of the Tamron 70-200 and then take the DA35 for closeups and interesting stuff like that.
I preferred the DA ltds to the FA Ltds outside, but outside I preferred the zooms as convenience and how it fits into my time spent outside.
So basically I kept the DA*Zooms, to be used both in studio and outside, the FA Ltds to be used in studio, and the only DA Ltd I kept was the DA35, and that is to do interesting POV shots up close, etc.. and I use it in the studio too. At infinity, the DA*16-50 is as good as the DA35 is.
For my next trip, I'll be picking up the Pentax DA 17-70 and the Tamron 70-200 and I'll take the DA35 for a 3-lens kit.