Originally posted by Butch5 I had looked at this lens too as a possibility. Nice!
The biggest issue with this lens is it doesn't play nice with the 1.7x TC. For those unfamiliar, the F 1.7x AF adapter adds limited AF to an A lens. So with an A*300 2.8, you get 510 ƒ4.5 using the TC. The 9.3 minimum aperture of the A-400 when using the 1.7x means it doesn't reliably auto focus.
I have trouble thinking I would buy a telephoto that had absolutely no AF ability even with the ƒ1.7 adapter. It's just one less piece of flexibility. The 400s, should have been ƒ4, not ƒ5.6. Then they'd be useful. ( They'd also be double the price.)
I love the idea of 680mm , my A-400 with the 1.7x, it just doesn't work. Maybe if the FA* is a little sharper, it would, who knows?
Ian says he can use a a TC on 600mm ƒ6.3 lens with his Nikon system, these things aren't written in stone.
One important factor in lens design is the size o the front element. The DA*200 and DA* 300 both take 77mm filters. The DFA 150-450 takes an 86mm filter. Thus has the potential to take in more light. Yet at 200mm the 200 is 2.8 and the 150-450 is 4.5. All the flexibility you gain in FL with the zoom, you lose in Aperture, especially when considering Aperture to weight ratio.