Why no review for the classic early-1970s Tokina-made
Vivitar-Soligor-Hanimex-Sears-Montgomery Ward-Mamiya-Yashica-Lentar-Porst-Et Cetera f/4.5 90-230mm zoom?
About 8 years ago, luisalegria over at the MFlenses forum wrote that it was "probably the most widely distributed, top-selling zoom lens of the 1970's, and maybe of all time, since that was the peak of the consumer SLR boom." Didn't we all own one of these? Or in the cases of younger PFers, didn't our grandparents own one of these? How many PFers still have a copy of this lens in their collection? There have to be a goodly number. If so, why don't our lens reviews mention this lens? (I've been searching them all morning--either it's not there or I need to see the optometrist.)
When I'm looking up info about legacy lenses or more recent lenses, the search engine nearly always pulls up a PFreview, and, if it doesn't, I know that I'm mainly going to find little more than charts of specifications--unless some photo blogger has done a longer review of that lens. PF is pretty much the only place to find a lot of thorough reviews of MANY lenses (most lenses with any Pentax compatibility!) with the added benefit of differing points of view, like when one PFer rates a lens a 10 for Sharpness, while another one calls it a 5! Thorough reviews with LOTS of perspective.
So, isn't it an oversight that the ubiquitous (luisalegria called it "common as dirt") many-labeled-Tokina 90-230 zoom doesn't have a review here with several contributors? It can't be because it's not good enough--many lenses, even Pentaxes, have poor ratings. And then if you look at what this photographer-blogger does with it on a few extension tubes [
robnunnphoto.com - Posts / Home - Soligor 90-230mm f/4.5 M42 Manual Focus Zoom LensReview ], you'd think the lens has the kind of potential that would make users what to shout about it.
Could it just be that this lens is forgotten? The assumption being that everything since the mid-1970s has surpassed it? I get it. I was thinking of getting rid of the Sears branded version I got locally in a case of old lenses listed on craigslist last summer. Heck, it can't even close-focus, I thought, and it weighs enough to be an artillery shell, I thought. I haven't even tried it out, beyond putting it on a camera and looking through it. But you can be sure I'll give it a serious try out, after looking at those photos by Rob Nunn in his blog!
So how about it, those PFers who have a copy of this lens squirreled away in our collections, let's redress this oversight and give this classic old hunk of metal and glass a PF review? I'm going to test mine out, both alone and with extension tubes and see what happens. Anyone I've inspired, please do the same. We can gather some first impressions and photos right in this thread, and when it all hits critical mass we'll get that proper PF review off of the ground.
Not sure if you have this lens? The Vivitar and Soligor versions seem to be the most common, many of them in a T4-mount, so your copy might or might not have a Pentax m42 screwmount T4 adapter on it. Some of them, like my Sears, are fixed mount. Some have 58mm filter threads, some 62mm. Many have a built-in hood, but perhaps not all. They all (or nearly all) have a tripod mount. If you search the auction site for "90-230mm" you'll see pictures of a lot of variations, priced from about $10 up to almost $100. The K-mount had not been invented when these lenses started being made, nor were there T4 K-mount adapters (originally at least). I did find a listing for a K-mount Sears-labeled 90-230mm lens there on ebay, but it doesn't look like the same lens to me, and it is hard to know if it is internally the same. It would be my guess that any K-mount versions are rare, though I'd love fellow PFers to prove me wrong about that if they can.
I'll post some pix of my lens here a little later.
Later, to post some pictures of one of the versions, my fixed-mount (not T4 adapter) m42 Sears:
Hmmmm? That's funny, it didn't look dusty before all that light hit the front of it! Now where's that blower brush....?
Last edited by goatsNdonkey; 01-06-2017 at 02:27 PM.
Reason: adding pictures