Originally posted by Zephos UPDATE: Hey everyone I just got a new idea since I might get a FF one day... what if I got the D-FA 28-105 ? I know that doesn't really help on the wide end but it certainly would fill in the gaps everywhere else.
28mm is a bit limiting at the wide end for some people, with a field of view equivalent to 42mm on full-frame.
It very much depends on what focal lengths are important to you, how much creative control you want over depth of field, and how much lower-light shooting you do.
I bought a Tamron 28-75 f/2.8 for portraiture on APS-C, but I've become very fond of it as a general-use walk-around lens. I find the focal length range very comfortable - and in that respect, I'd probably enjoy the greater range of the 28-105. But, I also like to have shallow depth-of-field for close-up, portraiture and pet photos, and the 28-105 is a little too slow at the longer focal lengths for my taste.
I also have the same Tamron lens on A-mount full-frame, and the experience of shooting those focal lengths with the larger sensor (and, hence, wider field of view / smaller effective "magnification") is very different, as I knew it would be - so that's something else to bear in mind if you buy a lens to use on your K-50 and later move to a K-1...