Originally posted by beholder3 Well, stacking with really strong multipliers does create the same situations you have with older low res sensors. They simply can not keep up with their pixel count on the details. I would assume on a 100 MPx APSC the crop would clearly outresolve the stacked TCs. So my intention was to comment on single TC usage.
Therefore I still would challenge anyone stating the result of most TCs (except a few very good x1,4s) is better than the crop on say a K-3 sensor.
But obviously there are always exceptions to the "rules".
There may be instances where using TCs doesn't provide better results than no TC, because the original lens already resolves all relevant detail without the TC.
But, there is also a point where you back up so much the lens no longer resolves all relevant detail. At that point adding a TC will for a time continues to resolve all relevant detail, until you move back so far you need either stacked TCs or a better lens.
SO while I'm sure there are lots of instances where no improvement is seen with a TC, there are also many instances where a TC improves the image considerably. That's why people buy TCs.
Understanding folks saying a TC doesn't ad more detail. - PentaxForums.com
I'm using the Tamron SP AF 300 2.8 LD [Il} which is screw drive, and I'd definitely like to use the AF. And the lens is rated a 10 for sharpness on the forum, easily good enough to benefit from a 2x TC.
I found an original listing somewhere on the Tamron site that said it would not work well with stacked TCs, and it doesn't. So I'm looking to extend my reach past 1.7x. The Tamron site also listed the matched TC that was released with the camera, but months of watching eBay hasn't found me one, so I'm looking to see what else I might use.
When I bought the lens , of course I hadn't read the stacked TC warning. SO I was seriously disappointed when I couldn't get the same results with the 300 I got with stacked TCs with my DA*200 2.8 on the K-3 which gives me 2.4x magnification. So 2x wouldn't even be what i was hoping for. But it would seem to be really hard to come up with even that.
Especially bad since the only current Pentax TC vignettes on the K-1.
The good thing is the 1.7x gives me 510mm ƒ4.5 and is spectacular on the K-3. The focusing rotation on the Tamron is very loose and very short, probably the easiest lens you can buy for use with the 1.7x. One little pinky on the focus ring, it turns to close focus incredibly quickly, and then the 1.7x locks focus, usually immediately.
But I still want the option of 600 5.6 with AF.