Originally posted by Des For full-frame or crop Bruce?...
Well... I was going to suggest for FF, but after realising that the KP does ES so much better I am now considering the lens to be chosen around the ASP-C sensor!
Originally posted by marcusBMG How much reach are you after? 400mm would be more recommendable for wildlife than 300mm and certainly 200mm. 200mm is a bit of an in between focal length, especially on apsc: not long enough for wildlife etc, tending to too narrow a FoV for more general use like portraiture... [/URL].
Yeh seems an odd length, nonetheless I think for my purposes 200mm is about as far as I can go.
Originally posted by luftfluss The Tak 200/3.5 is a special lens. Sharp wide open, beautiful bokeh, wonderfully smooth focus ring. Gotta watch the light, though, as it's prone to flare and bright cloudy skies can blow out the contrast.
The Tak 300/4 is sharp - sharper than the 55-300 (I've owned 2, but neither the HD nor PLM versions) - but CA is noticeable and the minimum focusing distance is long.
Both lenses can be suitable for large-ish wildlife. I like the Tak 200/3.5 for photographing little vignettes in nature - the lonely dangling leaf sort of thing - and really enjoy it's low-fi painterly rendering, which also punches up very well when you crank up the contrast in PP.
It's hard to make a recommendation without knowing your budget, usage intention (walk-around? tripod?).
Both the Tak 200/5.6 and 200/4 are usually available cheap, work well, and are sharper than the 55-300. I sold my 200/4, but the 200/5.6 is such a lovely little jewel that has lovely bokeh and deeper saturation than is usual for such a legacy lens.
I've got several other nice legacy tele lenses, but they are larger and more expensive.
Yes, I should have been more clearer on intent of purpose.
I'm looking for a lens that has a longer reach than my DFA 100mm 2.8, for the purposes of using in a church or lecture theater whereby I can mount the camera to a monopod, use ES, LV, Focus Peaking and take shots of the speaker or bride and groom, without flash and with minimal interference. It's predominately going to be used indoors, possibly in low light situations, so the wider aperture the better.
Yesterday I did more KP + DFA 100mm ES, LV, Focus Peaking shots using MF, it works pretty well, excellent stealth mode unlike the K-1 which clanks a little more.
For sure I'd take that combo out into the wild, I live in Australia, snakes, lizards, birds, plenty of things to shoot, but that would be secondary purpose and not main.
I've just realised that there are situations where AF is too noisy, but with Focus Peaking, ES and Manual mode (with a monopod to assist), the results can be excellent, especially on the KP where I can burst shoot as well.
If funds allowed I'd love the DA* 200 2.8, but currently that will have to wait, so was wondering if there was a good low light MF lens of approximately this reach that would do my task.
Weight is a factor I guess, the lighter the better for this task.