Originally posted by Steve Grosvenor Samyang 100–500 mm f5.6-7.1??
Has anyone had any experiences with this lens?
Looking for a cheap bird lens...
[Edit: I've revised my comments and added some details.]
While I haven't shot with my M42 mount Samyang 100-500 extensively, I've used it enough times to suspect you'd be better off using your 55-300 PLM instead (I don't own a 55-300).
My Samyang is soft at 500mm, its tripod collar is set too far to the rear for good balance and I find the 140 degree focus throw too short for precise focusing. On the plus side, my copy has very little zoom creep and it has a useful 2.5m minimum focus distance. And I haven't seen any significant flaring or CA.
I have several cheap, long lenses - each of which cost me under $100. Here they are:
Samyang 100-500mm f5.6-7.1, Phoenix/Samyang 500mm f/8 mirror, Adaptall 2 55BB 500mm f/8 mirror, MTO 3M-5CA 500mm f/8 mirror and Tele Vivitar 500mm f/6.3
A few months ago I did a sharpness comparison between these lenses with my K10D. Shot from a tripod, each lens is at f/8 from about 10m / 30 feet away. I focus bracketed and chose the best. These are 100% crops from the centers of the frames:
Of the five, my favorite to use is the Adaptall. It's much sharper than the Samyangs, more portable than the Vivitar and has a shorter minimum focus distance than the MTO (1.7m vs 4m). If you can live with doughnut highlights and a fixed aperture, I think it'd be a good choice.
I'm not much of a birder. But when they come and pose for me, even I can get a decent shot. This Towhee was lounging on the sidewalk and let me get pretty close. I had plenty of time to set up my tripod and get good focus with the 55BB and K10D. (50% crop, color and contrast added in post.):