In looking for a good, relatively inexpensive Pentax zoom for an all-around lens for my K100D I kept seeing comments that none could, of course, come close to a prime. So I borrowed a couple and did the following tests. You judge.
All are 100% crops of RAW images at 50mm (or so) @f/8 under identical conditions, and converted to jpeg without any post processing.
Why this range and that setting? Because it seemed like a good compromise, plus that's what I had access to and was interested in for a light, all-around lens (and yes, the 28-70 should be in there but it's too large and heavy for my needs right now). You be the judge...
First, the baseline 50 f/1.4
Second, the lowest forum-rated zoom (6.4), the FA 28-90 f/3.5-5.6
Next, the forum well-rated (9) F 35-105 f/4-5.6
Finally the equally well-rated (9) and only lens in this group still available new, the FA 28-105 f/4-5.6
And then, just for the helluvait, I grabbed the "worst" of the zooms (the plastic fantastic 28-90 that's available at about $60? ) at @ 73mm under the same conditions and compared it to the 77mm prime that costs literally 10 times more and has a whopping forum rating of 9.8...
First the 28-90
Finally, the 77mm
Last edited by FHPhotographer; 09-01-2008 at 10:26 PM.
Reason: added images